As the New York Yankees navigate the aftermath of Juan Soto’s departure to Queens, their signing of veteran first baseman Paul Goldschmidt might initially appear to follow a familiar and potentially concerning pattern. Yet beneath surface-level comparisons to Matt Holliday’s brief Yankees tenure lies a more nuanced story of late-season adjustments and renewed potential, according to those who know Goldschmidt best.

The historical echo in the Bronx

Joel Sherman of the Post recently highlighted the striking parallels between Goldschmidt’s arrival and Matt Holliday’s 2017 stint with the Yankees. “The slugger endured his poorest season as a Cardinal in his age-36 campaign just as a long-term contract concluded,” Sherman noted of both situations. The similarities extend beyond timing – Goldschmidt’s 2024 numbers (.245 average, 22 home runs, 65 RBIs) mirror Holliday’s final Cardinals campaign (.246, 20 HR, 62 RBI) with uncanny precision.

Even their contract histories align. “At seven years, $120 million, Holliday in January of 2010 signed for the most money at the time in Cardinals history. It was eventually usurped in March 2019 by Goldschmidt’s five-year, $130 million pact,” Sherman detailed. “Both were told even before the final season on those deals concluded that St. Louis would not have them back.”

Breaking the pattern: Signs of Goldschmidt’s revival

stlsportspage
However, Turner Ward, Goldschmidt’s longtime hitting coach, sees crucial differences that suggest a more optimistic outcome. Ward, who has worked with Goldschmidt since his minor league days and served as his hitting coach in both Arizona and St. Louis, witnessed a significant transformation during the latter stages of 2024.

“Over the last six weeks of the season, he got back to simplifying things,” Ward explained. “Hitting off a tee and things like that. Over the course of last season, his swing got out of sequence and he tried to do too much. Personally, I have no doubt he can get back to being the hitter he’s been.”

The statistics support Ward’s observation. After struggling through 98 games with a .658 OPS, Goldschmidt posted a .826 OPS over his final 56 games. Even more encouraging was his .920 OPS across the season’s final month, suggesting his adjustments were yielding tangible results.

Technical analysis: Understanding struggles and solutions

Ward’s intimate knowledge of Goldschmidt’s swing mechanics provides valuable insight into both the source of his 2024 struggles and the path to recovery. The veteran coach identified how Goldschmidt’s relentless pursuit of improvement occasionally worked against him.

“That’s not for everybody,” Ward noted, referring to Goldschmidt’s various technical experiments, including consultations with his bat manufacturer and time spent at Driveline Baseball. “We talked about it last year, he did some things I know had a negative effect on him. He sped up his upper half and that’s where the disconnect happened.”

The Yankee Stadium factor

One significant advantage Goldschmidt holds over previous veteran acquisitions is how well his hitting profile matches Yankee Stadium’s dimensions. “That place is made for a left-handed pull hitter or a right-handed hitter that drives the ball the other way,” Ward emphasized. “He hits the ball to all fields. St. Louis was not a great place for a guy who drives the ball the other way.”

The stark contrast in Goldschmidt’s 2024 home/road splits (.654 OPS at home vs. .774 OPS on the road) suggests the change in venue could significantly boost his production. Yankee Stadium’s shorter right-field porch and favorable dimensions for opposite-field power hitters align perfectly with Goldschmidt’s natural approach.

Leadership and mentorship beyond stats

The Yankees’ investment in Goldschmidt extends beyond his potential offensive contributions. Ward believes his impact on the clubhouse could prove equally valuable, especially following Soto’s departure.

“What’s really gonna help is he’s a guy that makes everyone around him better and they’ll make him better,” Ward observed. “He encourages everyone and he’ll be the one when guys are struggling that will be the voice of reason. What he went through this past year probably magnified that.”

Goldschmidt arrives in pinstripes not just as a seasoned first baseman, but as a seasoned mentor ready to shape the Yankees’ next generation. At 37, his journey from being mentored by veterans like Lyle Overbay to becoming a mentor himself comes full circle in the Bronx. The Yankees’ young core – including Ben Rice, Anthony Volpe, Austin Wells, Oswaldo Cabrera, and Oswald Peraza – stands to benefit from his presence both on and off the field.

The signing represents more than just filling a position – it’s about injecting proven leadership into the clubhouse. Goldschmidt’s reputation for nurturing young talent, combined with his ability to maintain elite performance well into his 30s, makes him an ideal bridge for a Yankees team balancing immediate competitiveness with long-term development.

By securing Goldschmidt, the Yankees address their first base uncertainty with a player known for both defensive excellence and consistent offensive production. The one-year commitment also preserves financial flexibility while providing stability at a position that has seen considerable flux. His addition exemplifies the front office’s strategy of blending veteran savvy with roster adaptability, potentially setting the stage for a seamless transition as the team’s younger players continue to develop.

A history of adaptation

Wendell Cruz-USA TODAY Sports
Those betting on Goldschmidt’s resurgence can find confidence in his track record of successful adjustments. Ward recalled Goldschmidt’s unconventional path to the majors in 2011 when he jumped directly from Double-A to the big leagues.

“I told [then Arizona GM] Kevin Towers, ‘This guy is going to do everything he needs to do to succeed there.’ And he did,” Ward remembered. “Some guys can adapt and make their own plan to dictate what they do at the plate. That’s where he took off.”

This adaptability, combined with Goldschmidt’s renowned work ethic, leads Ward to draw ambitious comparisons. “I played with Paul Molitor and Dave Winfield, Hall of Fame guys that played into their 40s. He’s so tough, fit, and mentally strong, I told him he could do the same thing if he wants to.”

Looking ahead to 2025

While the Yankees remain focused on immediate impact rather than long-term projections, the combination of Goldschmidt’s late 2024 improvements, favorable park factors, and proven adaptability suggests the potential for a significant bounce-back season.

The parallel to Holliday’s brief Yankees tenure provides an easy narrative, but Goldschmidt’s situation features crucial differences. His demonstrated ability to make adjustments, combined with a hitting profile well-suited to his new home ballpark, creates legitimate optimism for a revival in pinstripes.

As the Yankees prepare for their first season without Juan Soto, Goldschmidt’s veteran presence and potential offensive resurgence could prove vital to their championship aspirations. While history may echo previous veteran acquisitions, the specific circumstances surrounding Goldschmidt suggest he has the tools and opportunity to write his own unique chapter in Yankees history.