Saúl “Canelo” Álvarez and Terence “Bud” Crawford are both considered pound-for-pound boxing legends in their respective divisions. Canelo, a seasoned veteran with a wealth of experience at multiple weight classes, and Crawford, an undefeated fighter with remarkable technical ability, have stirred debate about what might happen if the two ever faced off in the ring. Recently, Joe Rogan, the renowned UFC commentator and podcaster, ignited this discussion with his bold assertion that “Canelo would kill Crawford.” While dramatic, Rogan’s statement opens up an interesting analysis of the potential matchup, one that pits raw power against technical precision.

Canelo Álvarez has built a career on facing and defeating top-tier opponents, rising through the ranks from super welterweight to light heavyweight. His ability to seamlessly transition between weight divisions is a testament to his versatility and skill. The Mexican fighter’s resume is packed with victories over elite names such as Gennady Golovkin, Sergey Kovalev, and Caleb Plant. Known for his devastating power, granite chin, and exceptional defense, Canelo combines a puncher’s knockout threat with the calculated ring IQ of a seasoned tactician. These traits have earned him recognition as the face of boxing in recent years.

On the other hand, Terence Crawford has remained undefeated throughout his career and has captured titles in multiple weight classes as well. Known for his switch-hitting ability, Crawford can fight seamlessly from either an orthodox or southpaw stance, confusing opponents and leaving them vulnerable to counters. His speed, footwork, and technical brilliance have made him a dominant force, especially in the welterweight division. However, unlike Canelo, Crawford has yet to test himself in higher weight classes against fighters who match Canelo’s size and strength.

This brings us to the crux of Rogan’s assertion. Weight classes in boxing exist for a reason—there is a distinct advantage to size, especially when accompanied by punching power. Canelo has fought as high as light heavyweight, where he stopped the much larger Sergey Kovalev. Standing at 5’8” with a reach of 70.5 inches, Canelo has adapted to fighting bigger men, developing a style that allows him to negate reach advantages with exceptional head movement and bodywork. His ability to break down larger opponents with power shots, especially to the body, makes him a dangerous foe for anyone venturing out of their natural weight class.

Crawford, in contrast, is naturally a smaller fighter. His career began at lightweight before moving up to welterweight, where he has dominated the competition. However, the welterweight division is significantly lighter than the divisions Canelo has been competing in recently. Canelo has the benefit of muscle memory and ring experience against physically stronger fighters, which is where Rogan’s argument likely stems from. In a hypothetical matchup, Canelo’s strength, power, and experience with bigger opponents would likely prove overwhelming for Crawford, who has yet to face a fighter with Canelo’s attributes.

Crawford’s advantage would lie in his technical prowess and adaptability. One of his greatest strengths is his ability to figure out opponents during a fight, making adjustments mid-round to exploit weaknesses. He is methodical, breaking down his opponents over time with precise counters and exploiting defensive lapses. Crawford’s ring IQ is among the highest in the sport, and his speed and footwork allow him to navigate the ring efficiently, making him a difficult target. If Crawford could avoid engaging in a brawl and keep Canelo on the outside, there is a possibility he could outbox the larger fighter over 12 rounds. However, this strategy would require near-perfection, as one lapse in defense against a puncher like Canelo could be disastrous.

One key factor in this potential matchup would be Canelo’s body shots. His ability to deliver punishing hooks to the body has debilitated larger men, and against a naturally smaller Crawford, this could be an even more potent weapon. Canelo’s bodywork is designed to break down opponents over the course of a fight, weakening their mobility and forcing them to drop their hands, leaving their head vulnerable to knockout blows. Crawford, while defensively sound, has never faced an opponent with such a relentless and effective body attack. If Canelo were to land consistently to Crawford’s midsection, it would be a serious challenge for Crawford to maintain his mobility and keep the fight at a distance.

Another consideration is how Crawford would handle Canelo’s pressure. Canelo is known for his ability to cut off the ring and force opponents into uncomfortable positions. His intelligent footwork, paired with his aggressive style, would make it difficult for Crawford to dictate the pace of the fight. While Crawford has proven he can fight on the inside and engage when necessary, doing so against Canelo might prove to be a costly mistake. The Mexican star’s combinations, especially in close quarters, are lethal. His uppercuts and hooks are designed to wear down his opponents, and if Crawford were to stand and trade with him, it’s likely he would come out on the losing end.

However, Crawford’s camp might argue that his undefeated record and dominance across multiple weight classes speak for themselves. The Nebraska native has a knack for rising to the occasion, as seen in his recent victory over Errol Spence Jr. His versatility and ability to switch stances mid-fight present unique challenges for any opponent, including Canelo. Crawford’s sharp counterpunching and defensive awareness could frustrate Canelo, potentially allowing him to score points on the judges’ scorecards. If Crawford can avoid Canelo’s power punches, maintain his distance, and execute a flawless game plan, it’s conceivable he could outpoint the Mexican over the duration of the fight.

Nevertheless, Rogan’s point about Canelo’s physicality and power holds weight. Crawford, though immensely skilled, has never faced someone with the blend of experience, size, and power that Canelo brings to the ring. The jump in weight classes would likely pose a significant challenge for Crawford, and history has shown that even elite fighters can struggle when moving up in weight. Canelo’s ability to absorb punches and dish out punishment is something that Crawford has not encountered before.

In conclusion, while Joe Rogan’s statement that “Canelo would kill Crawford” might be an exaggeration, it underscores the challenges Crawford would face in moving up to fight the Mexican star. Canelo’s combination of power, experience, and ability to adapt against larger opponents makes him a formidable foe for anyone, especially a smaller fighter like Crawford. While Crawford’s technical ability and ring IQ are undeniable, overcoming the size, strength, and pressure of Canelo would be a monumental task. The potential matchup would be a fascinating clash of styles, but the physical and experiential edge likely tilts in Canelo’s favor.

Watch video: