Adele heartbreak: Judge orders songstress’ hit off streaming platforms amid samba plagiarism claims by Brazilian artist

These are the 10 most emotional Adele songs, in case you need a good cry

Adele’s soulful ballad Million Years Ago has landed at the center of a legal storm, with a Brazilian composer claiming the song bears an uncanny resemblance to his 1995 samba hit, Mulheres. A judge in Brazil has ruled in favor of composer Toninho Geraes, 62, in the initial stages of the case, ordering Adele’s song to be removed from streaming platforms pending further investigation.

The ruling marks a significant victory for Geraes, who is demanding $160,000 in royalties and a songwriting credit for the track featured on Adele’s Grammy-winning 2015 album, 25.

Court Ruling Targets Streaming Platforms

The decision by the Brazilian court also directs Sony and Universal Music to cease all use, reproduction, and distribution of Million Years Ago. Lawyer Fredimio Trotta, representing Geraes, called the ruling a milestone for the global recognition of Brazilian music.

“This is a landmark for Brazilian music, which has often been copied to create successful international hits,” Trotta stated. “This ruling sends a message to international producers and artists to think twice before engaging in potential parasitic use of our rich musical heritage.”

Music fans have noted the similarities between Adele’s track and Mulheres, a samba classic celebrated for its intricate melodies and heartfelt lyrics. Geraes maintains that Million Years Ago mirrors key elements of his composition, sparking the plagiarism suit.

Past Controversies Add to the Debate

This is not the first time Million Years Ago has faced accusations of plagiarism. When the song was first released, critics drew comparisons to Acilara Tutunmak (Clinging to Pain), a 1985 track by Kurdish singer Ahmet Kaya. However, no legal action materialized in that instance, and Kaya passed away in 2000, leaving the claims unresolved.

The recent ruling reignites the conversation about originality in the music industry and the borrowing of cultural sounds. While Geraes stands firm in his allegations, music industry insiders expect Sony and Universal to appeal the decision.

Implications for Adele and the Industry

The court’s order to halt streaming and commercial use of Million Years Ago has sparked discussions about the protection of intellectual property across borders. Legal experts suggest the case could serve as a cautionary tale for international artists and producers who incorporate global influences into their work.

For Adele, the legal battle could tarnish her reputation as one of the world’s most celebrated singer-songwriters. Meanwhile, the delay in resolution means both sides face an extended period of legal wrangling before any final judgment is reached.

Despite the ongoing dispute, Geraes expressed optimism about the impact of the case on safeguarding Brazilian music. “This decision is not just about me; it’s about preserving the integrity of our cultural heritage,” he said.

Music fans and industry watchers alike will be closely following the case, as it could shape the standards for originality and influence in contemporary music.