The New York Yankees find themselves in an intriguing predicament as they evaluate their options regarding veteran hurler Marcus Stroman. As the 2025 season approaches, the organization faces the delicate task of managing an overflow in their starting rotation. While most teams dream of having surplus pitching talent, the Yankees must now carefully navigate this situation, weighing Stroman’s role against team dynamics and financial considerations.

The Yankees’ starting staff presents a picture of depth that many teams would envy. With a rotation anchored by ace Gerrit Cole and fortified by Carlos Rodon, Max Fried, Luis Gil, and Clarke Schmidt, Stroman’s position has become increasingly uncertain. The right-hander, who arrived in the Bronx through a two-year, $37 million deal in 2024, delivered a mixed bag in his inaugural season. His statistical line – a 10-9 record complemented by a 4.31 ERA and 113 strikeouts across 154.2 innings – while respectable, failed to secure him a spot in the postseason rotation, prompting discussions about his role moving forward.

Market assessment and Stroman trade possibilities

Jason Szenes@NYP
Stroman’s contract structure presents unique considerations in trade discussions. His 2025 salary of $18 million, coupled with a vesting option worth $18.33 million for 2026, creates both opportunities and obstacles in potential deals. While his proven ability to consume innings makes him an attractive target for pitching-hungry teams, his 2024 performance metrics and substantial salary obligations have complicated trade negotiations.

Recent reports indicate that the Yankees explored a potential deal with the St. Louis Cardinals, attempting to package Stroman in a trade centered around third baseman Nolan Arenado. Despite the Cardinals’ openness to moving Arenado as part of their rebuild, Stroman’s contract emerged as a sticking point. The market has also generated buzz around other potential suitors, including the Toronto Blue Jays, Arizona Diamondbacks, and Boston Red Sox, though concrete discussions have yet to materialize.

Exploring trade returns

New York Daily News
The Yankees’ pursuit of trade partners could yield various returns depending on the destination. A reunion with the Toronto Blue Jays, where Stroman began his MLB journey, might result in promising young talent. Potential targets could include third-base prospect Addison Barger or other highly-ranked prospects within Toronto’s system. Similarly, discussions with the Diamondbacks or Braves might focus on emerging talent in exchange for Stroman’s veteran presence.

Atlanta’s situation warrants particular attention. The departures of Max Fried and Charlie Morton via free agency have created significant rotation needs. Stroman’s durability and experience could provide valuable stability for the Braves’ pitching staff. As noted by Newsweek’s Zach Pressnell, a package of mid-tier prospects could satisfy both teams’ objectives while addressing the Yankees’ payroll considerations.

A bullpen alternative? A strategic pivot

R.J. Johnston/Toronto Star
Should trade efforts prove unsuccessful, the Yankees might explore transitioning Stroman to a relief role. Despite his career-long identity as a starter, his diverse pitching arsenal and stamina could translate effectively to long relief or strategic bullpen deployment. However, this alternative raises questions about the financial wisdom of allocating $18 million to a relief pitcher.

Stroman’s brief relief appearances during the 2024 postseason offered glimpses of his potential effectiveness in this capacity. Initially excluded from the Division Series roster, he later contributed meaningful innings in the ALCS, demonstrating adaptability in a new role. While this approach could maximize his value to the team, it remains uncertain whether Stroman would embrace such a transition.

Strategic considerations moving forward

Examining Stroman’s broader career provides an important context for any decisions about his future. His cumulative statistics – an 87-85 record with a 3.72 ERA over 261 appearances – reflect consistent performance at the major league level. Perhaps most importantly, his reliability stands out; since 2015, he has consistently pitched 135 or more innings each full season, excluding only the 2020 COVID-shortened season, which he opted to sit out. This track record of durability enhances his appeal to teams seeking rotation stability.

The Yankees’ decision-making process regarding Stroman encompasses multiple factors. While trading him could create financial flexibility and clarify roster construction, identifying an appropriate trade partner presents significant challenges. The bullpen option offers a creative solution for utilizing his talents, though this approach might conflict with both financial efficiency and player preferences.

As winter progresses, the Yankees must carefully evaluate their options. The ongoing need for pitching depth across the league could potentially expand the market for Stroman’s services, creating opportunities for mutually beneficial transactions. Whether through a trade or role modification, Stroman’s situation remains a crucial element in the Yankees’ preparations for the upcoming season. The resolution of this situation will likely impact both the team’s roster composition and financial flexibility as they pursue their championship aspirations in 2025.

What do you think? Leave your comment below.