In the aftermath of Gleyber Torres’s departure to free agency, the New York Yankees find themselves exploring various options to reinforce their infield alignment. Among the candidates under consideration, veteran infielder Paul DeJong has emerged as a potential solution, according to recent reporting by Jon Heyman of the New York Post. This development signals the Yankees’ pragmatic approach to roster construction as they navigate the complexities of their 2025 roster needs.

The DeJong chronicles: A career of contrasts

Paul DeJong’s professional journey presents a compelling narrative of resilience and adaptation. Since his 2017 debut with the St. Louis Cardinals, following his selection in the fourth round of the 2015 draft, DeJong has experienced both the heights of MLB success and the challenges of maintaining consistency at the game’s highest level. His initial three-year run showcased remarkable promise, evidenced by a robust .251/.318/.467 slash line and an impressive 108 wRC+. The pinnacle of this early success came in 2019 when DeJong’s 30-home run campaign earned him All-Star recognition while his defensive excellence solidified his reputation as a premium shortstop.

However, the trajectory of DeJong’s career took an unexpected turn following the COVID-shortened 2020 season. The subsequent four-year period saw his offensive production decline significantly, resulting in a modest .207/.285/.368 line and an 80 wRC+. This downturn led to his eventual departure from St. Louis in 2023, followed by brief and unremarkable stints with both the Toronto Blue Jays and San Francisco Giants before finding a new opportunity with the Chicago White Sox.

Yankees enticed bu his resurgence in 2024

MLB
The 2024 season marked a significant turnaround in DeJong’s career narrative. Securing the starting shortstop role with the White Sox, he demonstrated renewed productivity that ultimately attracted the attention of the Kansas City Royals, who acquired him mid-season. Adapting to a new role at third base to accommodate Bobby Witt Jr., DeJong finished the year with meaningful contributions: a .227/.276/.427 slash line (95 wRC+), 24 home runs, and defensive versatility that contributed to a respectable 1.7 fWAR.

Despite this resurgence, certain aspects of DeJong’s game remain concerning. His .276 on-base percentage ranked among MLB’s lowest figures, while his 32.4% strikeout rate stood as the third-highest among qualified hitters with 450 or more plate appearances. Nevertheless, his power output and defensive flexibility present intriguing value propositions for teams seeking infield depth.

Yankees’ infield dilemma

The Yankees’ current infield configuration presents several challenges requiring attention. Jazz Chisholm Jr., acquired during the previous season’s trade deadline, projects as a starter at either second or third base. The remaining infield positions could potentially be filled by a combination of existing options:

DJ LeMahieu: The veteran infielder’s struggles in 2024, marked by a disappointing 52 wRC+, raise significant questions about his role moving forward. At 36, concerns about his ability to bounce back loom large.
Oswald Peraza: Despite his potential, Peraza’s limited major league experience (74 games) makes him something of an unknown quantity at the highest level.
Oswaldo Cabrera: While his defensive versatility provides value, Cabrera’s offensive output (.247/.296/.365, 88 wRC+) falls short of typical expectations for a contending team.

The addition of DeJong could provide strategic depth and allow the Yankees to optimize their current personnel in more suitable roles.

Financial considerations shape strategy

AP Photo/Bryan Woolston
The Yankees’ interest in DeJong reflects a broader organizational strategy that prioritizes fiscal responsibility following several high-profile acquisitions. Having already secured Max Fried, Paul Goldschmidt, Cody Bellinger, and Devin Williams this offseason, the team appears hesitant to pursue premium infield options like Alex Bregman or Nolan Arenado, who would require substantial financial commitments or valuable trade assets.

DeJong represents a more economical alternative that aligns with the team’s current financial parameters. Heyman’s reporting suggests that moving Marcus Stroman‘s $18 million salary could create additional flexibility for roster improvements. While DeJong may not possess star-level impact, his combination of affordability and reliable defense makes him an attractive option for a team mindful of luxury tax implications.

Evaluating DeJong’s potential Bronx impact

AP Photo/Matt Slocum
DeJong’s skill set could complement the Yankees‘ existing roster in several ways. His power potential could be amplified by Yankee Stadium’s favorable dimensions, particularly the short right-field porch that might help him exceed his 2024 home run total. His defensive versatility at both shortstop and third base addresses a critical need for improved infield defense following the team’s defensive struggles in the 2024 postseason.

However, potential concerns exist. DeJong’s high strikeout rate and limited on-base skills could exacerbate existing offensive inconsistencies within the lineup. His recent performance history suggests he might be better suited as a complementary piece rather than a primary contributor.

Any acquisition of DeJong would likely represent a transitional solution while the Yankees evaluate long-term options. His presence could provide valuable time for prospect development or create flexibility for exploring more impactful trades as the season progresses.

The potential addition of Paul DeJong exemplifies the Yankees’ current approach to roster construction – balancing competitive ambitions with financial prudence. While he may not generate the excitement of a marquee acquisition, DeJong’s power potential, defensive adaptability, and veteran presence could fulfill an important role in the Yankees’ 2025 campaign. As Brian Cashman and the front office continue to evaluate their options, the resolution of the infield situation remains a crucial element in the Yankees’ pursuit of championship contention. Whether through DeJong’s acquisition or alternative solutions, the team’s infield composition will significantly influence their prospects for success in the upcoming season.