As the MLB offseason heats up, the New York Yankees find themselves in a complex situation regarding free-agent first baseman Christian Walker. While Walker’s defensive prowess and leadership are undeniable, the 33-year-old’s age, contract demands, and draft-related penalties have thrown a wrench into the Yankees’ plans.

Age concerns in Yankees’ contract talks

The Yankees’ hesitation stems primarily from Walker’s age. At 34, he remains a formidable presence on the field, earning three Gold Gloves at first base. However, long-term contracts for players in their mid-30s often come with risks. According to MLB insider Joel Sherman, the Yankees are unwilling to offer Walker a multi-year contract beyond two seasons—a term Walker reportedly finds unappealing.

Walker’s age affects not only contract length but also the Yankees’ payroll flexibility. His expected salary would likely be substantial, making the Bombers cautious about committing significant resources to a player nearing the latter stages of his career.
CBS

Walker deal to cause draft pick implications

Adding to the complexity is the draft-pick compensation tied to Walker’s free-agent status. After rejecting a qualifying offer from the Arizona Diamondbacks, Walker’s signing would cost the Yankees significant draft capital. Having already surrendered international bonus pool money and two draft picks to sign left-hander Max Fried, adding Walker would mean forfeiting even more critical picks—potentially their third- and sixth-highest selections in the 2025 draft.

MLB Trade Rumors’ Mark Polishuk noted that the Yankees face these penalties with any free agent who declined a qualifying offer, making a trade for a first baseman a more appealing alternative.

Alternative options

Given the financial and draft-related hurdles, the Yankees have explored trade options. They reportedly inquired about Cody Bellinger from the Chicago Cubs. Bellinger, a left-handed slugger, could be a better fit for Yankee Stadium’s dimensions. Other potential targets include Yandy Díaz of the Tampa Bay Rays and Josh Naylor of the Cleveland Guardians, both of whom could provide power and versatility.

Gary A. Vasquez-USA TODAY Sports
Another potential trade candidate could be Ryan Mountcastle from the Baltimore Orioles, a promising young first baseman with offensive upside. Mountcastle’s powerful bat and controllable contract make him an appealing target for the New York team, who are eager to maintain long-term flexibility while boosting their current roster.

The Yankees’ decision on Walker will likely come soon, given mounting interest from other teams, including the Washington Nationals. While Walker’s bat and glove would significantly improve New York’s infield, the cost—both financial and strategic—might be too steep.

Beyond Walker, the Yankees could consider reallocating resources to shore up other areas of need, such as the outfield or pitching rotation. They have been linked to several top free-agent pitchers and outfielders, suggesting a multi-faceted approach to roster improvements.

As the offseason progresses, the Yankees must weigh the value of proven veteran leadership against the long-term consequences of sacrificing draft capital and cap space. Whether through a free-agent signing or a well-crafted trade, their choice will undoubtedly shape their 2025 season and beyond.

What do you think? Leave your comment below.