As the New York Yankees’ offseason headlines swirl with speculation about Juan Soto and roster adjustments, one name has quietly faded into the background: DJ LeMahieu. Once a cornerstone of the team’s lineup and a two-time batting champion, he is now an uncertainty. After a brutal 2024 season marred by injuries and underperformance, the question looms: can LeMahieu reclaim his place as a meaningful contributor in 2025?

LeMahieu’s 2024 campaign was a season riddled with setbacks, beginning with a delayed start due to a broken foot. The injury sidelined him for a significant portion of the year, and when he did return, the veteran never seemed to find his stride. Slashing a career-worst .204/.269/.259 with just two home runs and seven extra-base hits across 67 games, LeMahieu’s struggles were evident at the plate. His season ended prematurely with a hip impingement, forcing him to watch the Yankees’ march to the World Series from the sidelines.

This marked a stark decline for the player who, just a few years prior, was the team’s leadoff hitter and a trusted infielder. The 36-year-old’s decline wasn’t entirely unexpected, given his injury history, including a nagging foot and toe issue in 2022. However, 2024 was a low point, raising concerns about his ability to bounce back.

The Yankees’ perspective: Hope over reality

AP Photo/Ryan Sun
Yankees General Manager Brian Cashman expressed cautious optimism about LeMahieu’s future during the GM Meetings. “I’m certainly hopeful that at some point DJ LeMahieu can play a role for us,” Cashman said. However, he also left the door open for alternative plans, noting the need to evaluate all roster options.

Manager Aaron Boone echoed similar sentiments at the Winter Meetings, emphasizing LeMahieu’s potential value if healthy. “I would never cross off a player of his caliber, even though it’s been obviously a tough couple of years,” Boone stated. He highlighted the strides LeMahieu made in regaining his health toward the end of the season but acknowledged that consistent health remains the key to any resurgence.

LeMahieu’s versatility in question

LeMahieu’s versatility—he can play first, second, and third base—was once a significant asset for the Yankees. However, with the team already boasting several flexible defenders and LeMahieu’s bat faltering, his utility role is no longer guaranteed. While there is hope that he could serve as a valuable bench piece, the Yankees’ depth in the infield raises doubts about his role on the 2025 roster.

Boone left room for optimism, saying, “I’m still not going to be surprised if DJ hits on some level for us. It comes down to health and can he maintain that health to allow him to put out his at-bat, his approach, his swing.”

The financial factor

One of the biggest obstacles to moving on from LeMahieu is his contract. The veteran infielder still has two years and $30 million remaining on the six-year, $90 million deal he signed before the 2021 season. While the Yankees have a history of eating costly contracts to move players who no longer fit the roster—examples include Aaron Hicks, Alex Rodriguez, and Jacoby Ellsbury—doing so with LeMahieu would be another hefty financial blow.

Given the remaining value on his deal, the Yankees appear willing to give LeMahieu another chance to prove himself during Spring Training. However, if his performance and health do not improve, parting ways could become a real consideration before Opening Day.

A potential path forward

X-@mealicea9
For LeMahieu, the road to redemption hinges on one factor: health. Injuries have sapped his consistency and effectiveness, but there’s hope that a full offseason of recovery and preparation could help him regain some of his previous form. If he can return as even a shadow of the player who won batting titles in 2016 and 2020, he could provide value as a part-time contributor.

The Yankees, however, are not banking on LeMahieu returning to his All-Star level. The team’s offseason priorities have focused on addressing other needs, leaving LeMahieu’s future uncertain. Still, his presence as a veteran with postseason experience could prove useful in a limited role if he shows improvement in Tampa.

The final countdown?

As the Yankees prepare for Spring Training, LeMahieu’s status will be one of the more intriguing storylines to follow. Will the 36-year-old defy the odds and carve out a meaningful role on a championship-contending roster? Or will the Yankees decide that his time in pinstripes has run its course?

For now, the organization is holding out hope, albeit cautiously. Boone summed it up best: “We’ll see. He got a lot healthier by the end of the season… I feel really good about where he was at the very end of the season physically.” The next few months will determine whether that optimism is warranted—or if LeMahieu’s tenure in the Bronx has quietly come to an end.

One thing is clear: the clock is ticking for DJ LeMahieu, and his future with the Yankees hangs in the balance.

What do you think? Leave your comment below.