The New York Yankees’ offseason has been filled with high-stakes roster moves following their 2024 World Series appearance. Among the most debated topics is Juan Soto’s departure to the New York Mets after a one-year stint in pinstripes. Former MLB All-Star and ex-Yankees hitting coach Sean Casey, speaking on ‘The Mayor’s Office’ podcast, shared his thoughts on the Yankees’ prospects without Juan Soto and offered insight into the outfielder’s past impact on team success.

Juan Soto’s immense talent is undeniable, but his career has sparked debates about whether his individual brilliance translates to team success. Casey highlighted that despite the slugger’s exceptional offensive skills, his previous teams, notably the San Diego Padres, struggled to win consistently.

“The biggest thing with Soto is he gives such good at-bats,” Casey said. “It made him better, but it made (Aaron) Judge better, too. Judge was getting pitched to or was able to see an incredible at-bat; what the guy has, what he’s throwing, wear him down a little bit.”

Despite praising Juan Soto’s ability to elevate teammates with disciplined at-bats, Casey pointed out the Padres’ struggles while Juan Soto shared the field with superstars Manny Machado and Fernando Tatis Jr.

“When he went out to San Diego, they were out there, and he’s on that same team. They didn’t win with Machado and Tatis. I don’t know if they even made the playoffs that one year,” Casey reflected.

 

Casey: Yankees can win without Juan Soto

Charles Wenzelberg / NYP
The Yankees acted swiftly after losing Soto, bolstering their roster with major acquisitions. They signed left-handed ace Max Fried to an eight-year, $218 million contract, reinforcing their starting rotation. Additionally, the team traded for elite closer Devin Williams from the Milwaukee Brewers and brought in Cody Bellinger from the Chicago Cubs.

Bellinger, a former National League MVP in 2019 with the Los Angeles Dodgers, has seen a decline in offensive production in recent years. However, his defensive versatility as a center fielder and first baseman makes him a valuable asset for manager Aaron Boone’s lineup. Casey expressed confidence that the Yankees could offset Juan Soto’s departure with their recent moves. “At the end of the day, if you get some production from Bellinger and you bring in one other bat, you’re not losing a ton,” he said. His perspective highlights the Yankees’ strategy of building a balanced roster rather than relying solely on star power.

Bellinger’s addition, paired with the Yankees’ already potent offense led by Aaron Judge, could mitigate the void left by Juan Soto’s departure. Judge, coming off another MVP-caliber season, will continue to anchor the lineup, while emerging stars and offseason acquisitions aim to provide consistent support.

With Juan Soto now wearing Mets colors, the Yankees’ front office has clearly signaled its commitment to contending by reloading the roster. The additions of Fried, Williams, and Bellinger reflect a comprehensive approach focused on pitching dominance and defensive stability.

Moreover, the team’s sustained success in developing homegrown talent ensures that the Yankees remain perennial contenders. The organization’s aggressive yet calculated approach this offseason suggests they are determined to return to the World Series and secure the championship that eluded them in 2024.

While losing Juan Soto might have seemed like a significant blow initially, the Yankees’ offseason maneuvers indicate they are well-equipped to stay competitive. Sean Casey’s remarks underscore the complex nature of team-building in baseball — star power alone doesn’t guarantee success. With a revamped roster and an unwavering commitment to winning, the Yankees are poised to make another deep postseason run in 2025.

What do you think? Leave your comment below.