The New York Yankees are entering the 2025 season with a roster full of promise, having made several key additions to their team. Yet, one of the biggest gambles they might take doesn’t involve a flashy new signing or trade. Instead, it revolves around a familiar face: DJ LeMahieu. After battling injuries and inconsistent performance in recent years, can LeMahieu stay healthy and return to form as the team’s primary third baseman? If so, the Yankees could find themselves saving money while potentially catching lightning in a bottle.

After a turbulent 2024 season that saw LeMahieu play just 67 games due to injuries, the Yankees hope the 36-year-old veteran can bounce back and reestablish himself as a dependable force in the lineup and on defense. With Jazz Chisholm Jr. expected to shift to second base following Gleyber Torres’ departure in free agency, third base presents an opportunity for LeMahieu to reclaim his role and make an impact.

LeMahieu’s journey: From MVP candidate to question mark

LeMahieu’s early years in New York were nothing short of spectacular. During the 2019 and 2020 seasons, he established himself as one of the most reliable hitters in baseball, finishing as an MVP finalist and earning two Silver Slugger awards. However, the past few seasons have told a different story. A lingering toe injury in 2022 and its residual effects in 2023 took a toll on his swing mechanics and power output. While he remained a versatile defender, his offensive production dipped, leading to questions about his long-term role with the team.

In 2024, LeMahieu stayed relatively healthy but failed to reach his previous heights, leaving many wondering if age and wear-and-tear have permanently limited his upside. Now 36 years old, the veteran infielder faces perhaps his most pivotal season yet.
X@TheJudge44

The case for LeMahieu at third base

LeMahieu’s versatility has always been one of his greatest assets. He has shown the ability to play first, second, and third base at a high level, with Gold Glove-caliber defense. Placing him at third base full-time could provide the Yankees with stability at a position that has seen rotation and inconsistency in recent years. It also allows the team to focus their financial resources elsewhere, as LeMahieu is already under contract through 2026.

With a $15 million annual salary, LeMahieu’s performance relative to his pay is a critical factor. If he can regain even a fraction of his MVP-caliber form, the Yankees would essentially be getting high-level production at a discount. This would be particularly valuable for a team that has invested heavily in marquee players like Aaron Judge and Gerrit Cole, while also navigating the financial implications of recent trades and signings.

The Yankees’ third base dilemma arose as a consequence of roster adjustments during the 2024 season. Jazz Chisholm Jr., who admirably filled in at third base down the stretch and into the playoffs, is slated to return to his natural position at second base following Torres’ free agency exit. This leaves a significant vacancy at third base—one the Yankees are optimistic DJ LeMahieu can fill if he can stay healthy.

According to MLB insider Jon Heyman of The New York Post, “Yankees people love Alex Bregman but question whether Yankee Stadium is right for him. Possible they hope DJ LeMahieu regains health to fill 3B.” The comment reflects the Yankees’ cautious approach in addressing third base, with internal solutions like LeMahieu being prioritized over potentially high-cost external acquisitions.

Health is the key variable

LeMahieu’s health remains the biggest question mark. At 36 years old (turning 37 during the 2025 season), durability will be a critical factor in his ability to contribute. Over the past two seasons, recurring injuries have limited his playing time and performance. The Yankees’ medical staff will play a pivotal role in ensuring LeMahieu enters Spring Training in peak condition.
G Fiume
The toe injury that hampered him in 2022 had a cascading effect on his performance, highlighting just how critical health is to his game. Reports suggest that LeMahieu has worked extensively this offseason to address his durability and regain the mobility and strength that defined his early years with the Yankees.

If LeMahieu can stay on the field and avoid further injuries, his skillset still aligns well with the needs of the Yankees. He remains a disciplined hitter with the ability to work counts, get on base, and provide situational hitting. His defense, too, could be a game-changer, particularly with a pitching staff that thrives on ground-ball outs.

The team’s faith in LeMahieu stems from his professional approach and work ethic. Despite his struggles, LeMahieu has consistently demonstrated a commitment to preparation and resilience. If he can avoid the injury woes that derailed him in 2024, there’s reason to believe he can provide league-average offensive production while excelling defensively.

The potential payoff

An additional, forward-looking benefit to this strategy is the financial flexibility it creates for the Yankees’ future. By avoiding major infield acquisitions now, the team positions itself to make impactful moves in next year’s free agent market. Potential targets like Vladimir Guerrero Jr. and Kyle Tucker could address long-term needs, especially given that Paul Goldschmidt’s contract is only for the 2025 season. Saving resources this season could allow the Yankees to capitalize on opportunities to secure top-tier talent in 2026.

Should LeMahieu return to form, the Yankees stand to benefit in multiple ways:

Cost Savings: Utilizing LeMahieu as the primary third baseman eliminates the need to spend big on free agents or swing a costly trade for another infielder.
Roster Flexibility: LeMahieu’s ability to cover multiple infield positions provides insurance in case of injuries elsewhere on the roster.
Veteran Leadership: As a seasoned player with postseason experience, LeMahieu brings intangible value to a clubhouse that aspires to championship contention.

A calculated gamble worth taking

AP
Of course, there are risks involved. If LeMahieu’s injuries resurface or his offensive struggles persist, the Yankees could find themselves stuck with a declining player at a key position. This would not only hurt their production but also limit their flexibility to make in-season adjustments.

Ultimately, the Yankees’ decision to roll with DJ LeMahieu at third base in 2025 represents a calculated gamble. If he stays healthy and delivers, the move could pay off handsomely, providing the team with an affordable solution at third base while freeing up resources for other needs. And if not, the Yankees have the depth and resources to pivot mid-season.

Catching lightning in a bottle might be a long shot, but for a player of LeMahieu’s pedigree, it’s a bet worth making. The Yankees are banking on one of their most reliable veterans to remind everyone why he was once considered the heart of their lineup. If he succeeds, it could be one of the most important stories of their season—and a key factor in their pursuit of a 28th championship.

What do you think? Leave your comment below.