Young defenseman David Jiricek, selected 6th overall by the Columbus Blue Jackets in 2022, garnered significant attention this season.

His name surfaced in trade rumors, with the Montreal Canadiens reportedly showing interest, but he was ultimately traded to the Minnesota Wild.

With his imposing size, powerful shot, and defensive abilities, Jiricek was once considered a promising prospect.

However, the past two years of his development have raised some concerns.

According to experts like Mathias Brunet and Anthony Marcotte, Jiricek’s arrival in Montreal might not have been the best decision.

Marcotte points out that the Canadiens already have a similar player in Logan Mailloux.

Moreover, Jiricek’s development trajectory shows certain gaps that could hinder his adaptation to the NHL.

Simon Nemec would be a much better target for the Canadiens than David Jiricek according to several analysts.

Nemec, a young Slovak defenseman for the New Jersey Devils, stands out as an intriguing alternative.

Selected 2nd overall in the 2022 draft, right after fellow countryman Juraj Slafkovsky, Nemec is viewed as a well-rounded defenseman with high hockey IQ.

Several analysts, including those at RDS, consider Nemec a better fit to address the Canadiens’ long-term defensive needs. Kent Hughes will need to carefully weigh his options.

Jiricek may have presented an opportunity, but Nemec’s potential and compatibility might align more closely with the team’s long-term vision.

This situation remains one to watch, as speculation around Nemec and other young defensemen continues to fuel debates.

After Jiricek’s move to Minnesota, could another top defensive prospect from the 2022 draft be traded next?