Yankees outfielders Juan Soto and Aaron Judge begin the regular season in Houston.

In the ever-evolving saga of New York baseball, the latest chapter unfolds through pixels rather than pitches. The Yankees’ towering captain Aaron Judge has sparked intense discussion with his understated yet unmistakable commentary on Juan Soto’s departure to the Mets. As the baseball world continues to process Soto’s historic $765 million agreement with the crosstown rivals, Aaron Judge’s digital gesture has added an intriguing dimension to this developing narrative.

The disapproval in the digital age

In an era where social media serves as a platform for both celebration and subtle messaging, Aaron Judge’s recent year-end retrospective post has captured the baseball community’s attention. The carefully curated collection showcased memorable moments from the Yankees’ 2024 campaign, featuring an array of teammates, organizational personnel, and even Aaron Judge’s canine companions. However, the conspicuous absence of Juan Soto—a central figure in the team’s World Series run—spoke volumes without uttering a word.


The online community quickly seized upon this calculated omission. One user on X.com pointed out, “Bro included Verdugo over Soto LMFAO,” highlighting the inclusion of Alex Verdugo while excluding the more prominent Soto. The sentiment was echoed across social platforms, with supporters declaring, “Good. Aaron Judge is too good for him,” and others emphasizing, “Good he didn’t want to be a Yankee.” The digital discourse reached a point where some fans rhetorically questioned, “Who is this Juan Soto that you are referring to?”

Soto’s brief but brilliant Bronx tale in Aaron Judge’s company

The statistical footprint of Soto’s singular season in pinstripes tells a compelling story of excellence. Following his acquisition from San Diego in December 2023, the Dominican slugger delivered a performance that justified the substantial prospect package surrendered to acquire him. His regular-season numbers—a .288 batting average, complemented by 41 home runs and 109 RBIs—demonstrated his elite offensive capabilities. The postseason saw Soto elevate his game further, posting an impressive .327 average while contributing four home runs and nine RBIs during the Yankees’ World Series campaign.

The pairing of Aaron Judge and Juan Soto in the 2024 Yankees lineup drew comparisons to the legendary duo of Lou Gehrig and Babe Ruth, one of the most iconic tandems in baseball history.
Juan Soto celebrating with Aaron Judge after scoring a home run on October 14, 2024, during the Yankees' 5-2 win in ALCS Game 1 against the Cleveland Guardians at Yankee Stadium.Yankees
In 2024, the pair showcased a similar level of synergy. Aaron Judge, with his towering home runs and clutch performances, mirrored the show-stopping power Ruth brought to the Yankees. Soto, on the other hand, drew comparisons to Gehrig for his consistent ability to reach base, drive in runs, and provide a reliable presence in the lineup day in and day out.

One particular statistic added fuel to this comparison: Aaron Judge and Soto combined for over 99 home runs and 234 RBIs during the 2024 regular season, numbers that hadn’t been seen in the Bronx since Ruth and Gehrig’s heyday. Beyond the stats, their ability to energize the Yankees’ fan base and intimidate opposing pitchers evoked memories of the impact Ruth and Gehrig had on the game.

One of the most endearing aspects of the Aaron Judge-Soto partnership was their creation of a unique celebration that became a hallmark of the 2024 season: the “pinstripe handshake.” The celebration quickly gained traction, with fans and teammates alike joining in.

The complex web of fan feeling

The Yankees‘ faithful have expressed a complex mixture of emotions regarding Soto’s departure. While the financial magnitude of the Mets’ offer provides clear context for his decision—ensuring generational wealth for his family—the choice to join the crosstown rivals has struck a particularly sensitive chord with the Bronx faithful. Social media platforms have become forums for expressing this emotional turmoil.



Aaron Judge’s digital gesture appears to resonate with these sentiments. As the team’s acknowledged leader, his social media choices carry significant weight in shaping team culture and fan perception. The deliberate exclusion of Soto from his year-end tribute seems to align with supporters who prioritize organizational loyalty above individual achievement.

Yankees better after Soto’s exit

The 2024 season represented a period of both triumph and learning for the Yankees organization. While securing the American League pennant marked a significant achievement, their World Series performance highlighted areas requiring attention. The front office has responded proactively, securing talents like Max Fried, Cody Bellinger, and Devin Williams to address roster deficiencies.

Aaron Judge’s continued presence provides stability amid these changes. His leadership role takes on renewed importance as the team integrates new personnel and adapts its strategic approach. His recent social media activity suggests an active role in maintaining team culture and organizational values during this period of transition.
Juan Soto, now wearing a Mets cap and pinstriped Mets jersey, stands behind a podium at a press conference. (left)/Aaron Judge and Juan Soto, both in New York Yankees pinstriped uniforms, lean on a dugout railing with a “World Series 2024” sign just below them (right)
As Soto prepares to write his next chapter in Queens, the expectations accompanying his record-setting contract create unprecedented pressure. While his Yankees tenure demonstrated his capacity to excel under New York’s intense scrutiny, the challenge of justifying baseball’s richest contract presents a new level of responsibility. The intracity rivalry between the Yankees and Mets adds another layer of complexity to his situation.

The reflections

Aaron Judge’s calculated omission of Juan Soto from his digital retrospective represents more than mere social media drama. It embodies the complex dynamics of modern baseball, where loyalty, financial realities, and team culture intersect in increasingly public ways. As the Yankees prepare for their 2025 campaign, Aaron Judge’s subtle statement reinforces his position as guardian of the organization’s traditions and values.

This latest development in the Soto narrative adds another fascinating layer to the Yankees-Mets rivalry. Whether this moment becomes a defining element of New York baseball lore or simply another footnote in the offseason chronicle remains to be seen. However, Aaron Judge’s digital gesture ensures that the Yankees’ response to Soto’s departure will be remembered for its understated yet powerful commentary on loyalty in modern baseball.

What do you think? Leave your comment below.