The two men suing Michael Jackson’s companies over alleged child sexual abuse by the late pop star suffered a huge setback in court, In Touch can report.
According to court documents obtained by In Touch, a Los Angeles Superior Court judge shut down Wade Robson and James Safechuck’s subpoenas seeking records from the Los Angeles Police Department, Los Angeles County District Attorney’s Office, and the Santa Barbara County District Attorney’s Office.
Michael’s companies being sued opposed the subpoenas.
Lawyers representing the defendants claimed the subpoenas had been denied by the court back in 2018.
Wade, 41, and James, 46, filed separate lawsuits in 2013 over alleged abuse Michael, who died in 2009 at the age of 50, committed against them as child.
Wade claimed the abuse started when he was seven and continued on for years. James said he met Michael as a child and the alleged abuse started during the singer’s Bad tour and went on for years.
The defendants have denied all allegations of wrongdoing and slammed the accusations. The lawsuits were initially dismissed by the court but then revived in the higher court years later.
The parties are now preparing for trial. Both men were featured in the HBO documentary Leaving Neverland where they revealed details of Michael’s alleged behavior.
The duo recently joined forces and will be going to trial together.
In opposition to the subpoenas, the defendants argued, “Beyond violating the clear language of the Court’s July 2018 Order, Plaintiffs’ subpoenas seek highly sensitive private documents related to non-parties, are an attempt to circumvent the protective order in another case from another court, and fail to comply with California law on pre-subpoena notices to consumers.”
“Specifically, California’s statutory and common law recognize privacy rights to images of deceased persons. Plaintiffs’ demand for certain documents—including photographs of Michael Jackson’s genitalia and naked body taken by police—represents an egregious violation of these privacy rights, and is simply beyond the pale,” the opposition read.
“Plaintiffs’ March 2024 Subpoenas are an appalling intrusion and violation of these privacy interests and have no legitimate purpose. These subpoenas seek, in relevant part, a highly sensitive and discrete set of documents,” the motion added. “Here, there is no legitimate justification for Plaintiffs’ gross attempt to violate the privacy of a man who has been deceased for almost a decade and to disturb his family’s ‘peace of mind and tranquility’ with our ‘sensation-seeking culture.’”
“Plaintiffs’ subpoenas must be quashed insofar as they are seeking these lurid images of Mr. Jackson. Indeed, allowing Plaintiffs to proceed with these subpoenas is particularly inappropriate given the circumstances surrounding the photographs,” they argued.
The judge agreed.
The order read, “Because the information sought in the subpoenas was already encompassed in the Court’s July 5, 2018, order quashing previous subpoenas to SBCDA, LACDA, and LAPD, and because Plaintiffs did not serve third parties with the requisite consumer notices prior to serving the subpoenas at issue, the Court grants Defendants’ motion and quashes the four deposition subpoenas at issue.”
However, the court did deny the defendant’s motion for attorney fees over the matter. The case is ongoing.
News
A video surfaces showing Liam Payne drunk and yelling with a whiskey bottle in hand just hours before his de@th, leaving fans ‘in disbelief’
In the days leading up to his tragic passing, Liam Payne was reportedly seen in a hotel lobby in Buenos Aires, appearing disheveled and asleep while clutching a bottle of whiskey. This sighting has raised concerns among fans and the…
Ben Shephard shocks the public by ‘boasting’ about having ‘conquered’ 16 girls during his university days, leading fans to feel outraged and unable to accept his view as ‘an achievement to be proud of’
Ben Shephard, the well-known television presenter and host of shows like “Good Morning Britain,” recently shared a surprising story from his university days that has intrigued fans and sparked conversations. During a candid interview, Shephard recounted an unusual experience from…
VIDEO: Even though they tried to hide it, Strictly viewers quickly noticed the “contemptuous attitude” Carlos Gu showed towards Nancy Xu in the latest episode of the show: “They’re no longer friends…”
The professional dancers Carlos Gu and Nancy Xu from Strictly Come Dancing have recently been at the center of speculation following their apparent fallout. The to were spotted at a recent event, seemingly keeping their distance from each other, which has…
Strictly Come Dancing fans noticed strained interactions between Wynne Evans and Katya Jones as they “kept their distance” amid controversy over “inappropriate conduct.”
Fans of “Strictly Come Dancing” have been left speculating about the relationship between one of the show’s popular couples following what many described as an “awkward” performance during a recent live episode. The chemistry and rapport between dance partners are…
Katie Piper shares her struggles with social media, blaming it for her ongoing ‘psychological torment’ related to her ‘unusual’ appearance, indicating a deep frustration with the platform’s impact on her mental health.
Loose Women star Katie Piper has taken to Instagram to hit back Loose Women panellist Katie Piper has shared an emotive post to Instagram, saying “this is beyond anything even I can handle.” Hitting back at online trolls, Katie shared…
Ruth Langsford has set clear expectations for the future girlfriend of her son Jack, driven by her own painful experiences from her marriage to Eamonn Holmes: “I can’t bear the thought of my son enduring the same heartache I went through!”
Ruth Langsford has recently opened up about her deep concerns for her son Jack in light of her split from Eamonn Holmes. The well-known television presenter expressed her worries, admitting that she fears for Jack as she doesn’t want him…
End of content
No more pages to load