The relief pitcher market continues to evolve this offseason, with veteran right-hander Tommy Kahnle emerging as a coveted target for multiple contenders. Insider Jon Heyman has reported that eight teams have expressed interest in the experienced reliever. While the specific teams remain undisclosed, Heyman previously indicated in December that the New York Yankees maintain strong interest in reuniting with their former bullpen asset.

2024: A year of excellence for Tommy Kahnle

At age 35, Kahnle demonstrated remarkable effectiveness throughout the 2024 season, compiling an impressive statistical line that included a 2.11 ERA, 1.148 WHIP, and 9.7 strikeouts per nine innings across 42.2 frames. His ability to generate ground balls at an exceptional 58.6% rate reinforced his value as a late-inning option.

Central to Kahnle’s success was his masterful deployment of a changeup, which he utilized on 73.1% of his pitches according to Statcast data. This pitch proved particularly devastating against left-handed batters, who managed just a .172/.267/.338 line against him over the previous two seasons. The changeup’s effectiveness was quantified by its +10 run value in 2024, marking it as one of the season’s most impactful pitches.

October adversity raises Yankees concerns

Kahnle’s postseason contributions in 2024 underscored his importance to the Yankees‘ bullpen, as he appeared in nine of their 14 playoff contests. His 8.2 innings of work yielded three runs (two earned) while recording seven strikeouts and seven walks. A particularly memorable moment came in ALCS Game 4, where he secured a save using exclusively changeups across all 18 pitches.

However, the postseason also brought challenges, most notably in World Series Game 5 against Los Angeles. Tasked with protecting a one-run advantage, Kahnle struggled uncharacteristically, allowing multiple baserunners and ultimately suffering the loss. Despite this setback, his overall 2024 performance reinforced his status as a reliable high-leverage reliever.

Deep Yankees connections

Yankees
Kahnle’s relationship with the Yankees organization spans multiple chapters, featuring three distinct tenures in pinstripes. Originally selected by New York in the fifth round of the 2010 MLB Draft, his journey included a departure via the 2013 Rule 5 Draft to Colorado, followed by a 2017 return through a trade with Chicago’s White Sox. After a stint with Los Angeles that included Tommy John surgery rehabilitation, Kahnle rejoined the Yankees prior to the 2023 season.

Over his combined six seasons in New York, Kahnle has maintained an impressive 3.31 ERA, establishing himself as a trusted member of multiple Yankees bullpens.

Current Yankees bullpen configuration

FOX
The Yankees’ relief corps has undergone significant transformation this offseason, highlighted by the additions of two-time All-Star closer Devin Williams and strikeout specialist Fernando Cruz. The retention of Jonathan Loáisiga and the presence of right-handers Luke Weaver, Jake Cousins, Mark Leiter Jr., and Ian Hamilton create a formidable right-handed core. However, the absence of dedicated left-handed options remains a strategic concern.

Recent reports have linked New York to left-handed free agents Tim Hill and Andrew Chafin as potential solutions to this gap. While this pursuit of left-handed relief could impact Kahnle’s fit, the Yankees’ traditional emphasis on pitching depth suggests room remains for his potential return. The possibility of adjusting the current right-handed alignment to accommodate Kahnle presents a manageable scenario.

Sources indicate Kahnle maintains a strong interest in returning to New York, with the organization seemingly reciprocating this sentiment. His established comfort within the Yankees’ environment and proven success in pinstripes create natural momentum toward a potential reunion.

Market dynamics

AP
Kahnle’s availability coincides with significant movement in the relief pitcher market. Following Jeff Hoffman’s recent signing, several prominent relievers remain available, including Tanner Scott, David Robertson, Kenley Jansen, Carlos Estévez, Kirby Yates, and A.J. Minter. Kahnle’s specialized skill set and consistent track record position him as an attractive option within this competitive landscape.

As the Yankees put the finishing touches on their 2025 roster, the decision regarding Kahnle involves multiple factors: bullpen depth requirements, financial parameters, and the ongoing search for left-handed relief options. While the Yankees have already enhanced their relief corps, the perpetual value of quality pitching depth cannot be overstated. Kahnle’s proven ability to handle high-leverage situations could provide crucial insurance for close games throughout the season.

For Kahnle personally, returning to New York would offer an opportunity to write another chapter in his Yankees story. For the organization, reacquiring a battle-tested reliever with postseason experience represents an intriguing possibility. Regardless of the outcome, Kahnle’s free agency remains one of the offseason’s most compelling narratives as teams finalize their bullpen configurations for 2025.