Baseball’s most prestigious honor stands poised to welcome new members as the 2025 Hall of Fame voting approaches its conclusion. Early returns suggest a particularly meaningful ceremony for the New York Yankees faithful, with former ace CC Sabathia and brief Yankees tenant Ichiro Suzuki leading the pack. However, the voting patterns reveal a stark contrast in fortunes for other Yankees alumni, with Andy Pettitte and Alex Rodriguez encountering significant resistance on their path to Cooperstown.

Sabathia surging ahead on first ballot

MLB
CC Sabathia’s journey to Cooperstown has gained remarkable momentum, with the former Yankees workhorse currently securing 91% of votes, substantially exceeding the required 75% threshold. Over his 19-year career spanning Cleveland, Milwaukee, and New York, Sabathia amassed an impressive 251-161 record while recording 3,093 strikeouts across 3,577.1 innings of work.

Perhaps no chapter in Sabathia’s career better exemplifies his excellence than his heroic 2008 stint with Milwaukee. Following a midseason trade, he nearly single-handedly propelled the Brewers to their first playoff appearance in 26 years, posting an extraordinary 1.65 ERA with seven complete games in just 17 starts. This remarkable run, coupled with his dominant stretch from 2007-2011 – including a Cy Young Award and World Series championship – underscores his credentials for first-ballot induction.

Sabathia’s statistical legacy places him in rarefied air. As just the third southpaw since 1920 to achieve both 250 wins and 3,000 strikeouts, joining Randy Johnson and Steve Carlton, his place among baseball’s pitching elite is secure. His career 116 ERA+ and 61.8 bWAR further reinforce his case as one of the premier left-handed pitchers in baseball history.

Strong case for Sabathia’s first-ballot induction

Frank Franklin II, AP
Sabathia’s candidacy extends beyond traditional metrics. In an era increasingly dominated by specialized roles and carefully managed workloads, his durability stands as a testament to a bygone era. With multiple seasons leading the league in innings pitched and 13 campaigns of 180+ innings, Sabathia embodied the concept of the workhorse starter.

His impact on the Yankees dynasty transcended statistics. His leadership qualities and clutch performances, particularly during the 2009 World Series championship run, exemplified the intangible qualities voters often seek in Hall of Fame candidates. His respected status throughout the game, both as a competitor and clubhouse presence, strengthens his case for first-ballot recognition.

Ichiro carving path to immortality

X.com/@CC_Sabathia
The baseball world appears ready to deliver an unprecedented honor to Ichiro Suzuki, as the Japanese sensation maintains a perfect voting percentage in early returns. Should this remarkable trend continue, Ichiro would join Yankees closer Mariano Rivera as the only player to achieve unanimous selection, writing another chapter in baseball’s illustrious history.

Ichiro’s credentials transcend traditional statistical benchmarks. Beyond his impressive 3,089 MLB hits, his record-setting 262-hit campaign in 2004 stands as a testament to his extraordinary hitting prowess. His unique approach to the game, combining exceptional bat control, elite defensive skills, and masterful baserunning, revolutionized how teams evaluated talent across international borders. His selection appears to be less a question of if, but rather whether he can maintain his unanimous voting status through final balloting.

Pettitte’s dream falling short again

Andy Pettitte’s case proves equally challenging, with the postseason hero securing just 31.1% of votes in his seventh year on the ballot. While his 256 career wins and October excellence build a compelling narrative, his admitted HGH use and relatively modest advanced metrics have failed to convince a significant portion of the electorate. Despite matching Sabathia’s 116 ERA+, Pettitte’s case lacks the overwhelming statistical dominance typically associated with Hall of Fame pitchers.
NYY

Beltran’s borderline battle

Carlos Beltrán finds himself navigating a precarious path to induction, currently polling at 76.2%. His statistical case appears robust – 2,725 hits, 435 home runs, and a .837 OPS paint the picture of a Hall of Fame-caliber career. However, his connection to the 2017 Astros sign-stealing controversy has complicated his candidacy. Nevertheless, current projections suggest he could join Sabathia and Ichiro in this landmark class.

Struggles for A-Rod, ex-Yankees

While some ex-Yankees surge toward induction, others face considerably more challenging paths. Alex Rodriguez, despite his 696 home runs and remarkable 117.5 career bWAR, continues to struggle in his fourth year of eligibility, garnering only 42.6% support. His connection to performance-enhancing substances continues to overshadow his otherwise stellar career achievements.

Other former Yankees face even steeper odds. Bobby Abreu (21.3%), Russell Martin (4.9%), and Brian McCann (4.1%) have failed to generate meaningful momentum, while Curtis Granderson and Troy Tulowitzki appear destined to fall off the ballot entirely with no early support.

The 2025 Class takes shape

This year’s ballot features 28 candidates, with Ichiro and Sabathia emerging as the clear frontrunners. Billy Wagner’s final year of eligibility has generated significant support, while Beltrán teeters on the edge of selection. The potential induction of Ichiro and Sabathia would further enhance the Yankees’ remarkable Cooperstown legacy, following the recent celebrations of Derek Jeter and Mariano Rivera.

As January 21st’s official announcement approaches, the baseball world eagerly awaits the final verdict. The subsequent induction ceremony, scheduled for July 26-27 in Cooperstown, promises to celebrate careers that transcended traditional boundaries and redefined excellence in their respective roles. For Ichiro and Sabathia, the ceremony would represent the ultimate recognition of careers marked by consistent excellence, unwavering determination, and a lasting impact on baseball’s rich tapestry.