Major League Baseball has undergone some dramatic changes in recent years that have altered the game. The designated hitter in both leagues, expanded playoffs and most recently the pitch clock.
But one idea that has been discussed and kicked around in recent months would be one of the most dramatic changes ever and completely change the very nature of the way the game has been played for more than 150 years.
It is the golden at-bat, and it is something that commissioner Rob Manfred casually mentioned this week on John Ourand’s podcast.
“There are a variety of (rule change ideas) that are being talked about out there,” Manfred said. “One of them — there was a little buzz around it at an owners’ meeting — was the idea of a “Golden At-Bat.”
The concept of the “Golden At-Bat” is simple enough — one time per game a team could choose any hitter in its lineup, whether it is their turn to hit or net, and send them up to the plate for an at-bat.
It is not an imminent rule change, but the fact it is being talked about and the fact the commissioner is comment on it is a pretty good sign that it is something that it is being seriously considered down the line.
It should stay an idea and never go beyond that.
While it could certainly add some intrigue to games and another layer of strategy for managers, it still seems like more of a gimmick than anything else. And it is too dramatic of a change to the way the sport is played.
You set a batting lineup, and that is it. How the game unfolds after that is up to the play on the field.
The pitch clock was always seen as controversial to baseball purists, but it does not change the way the game is played. It just makes it happen faster. The designated hitter might have its critics, but again, it is still a basic concept with a batter in the lineup hitting in order.
The Athletic’s Jayson Stark outlined a couple of possible ways the rule could be implemented, including limiting it to only at-bats before the seventh inning, or only allowing teams that are trailing to use it late in games.
There is also the possibility that a team could choose a hitter for the “Golden At-Bat” before their spot in the lineup, creating the possibility for them to hit two times in a row.
This idea, by the way, has already been put into practice with the Savannah Bananas, baseball’s answer to the Harlem Globetrotters.
In that setting, it is fine. You go into a Savannah Bananas game expecting to see chaos, randomness and something that vaguely resembles a baseball game.
But it is a gimmick that has no place in real, competitive baseball games at the highest level of the sport.
Yeah, it would create some additional drama. But it would also rob the game of some of its greatest, most magical and most unexpected moments. Bucky Dent’s home run against the Boston Red Sox does not exist in a game or league where the New York Yankees could simply say, “Hey, Reggie Jackson, go hit again even though it is not your turn in the lineup.”
Baseball can make changes. It can try to add more intrigue. But it should stay away from gimmicks. This feels too gimmicky. It should stay in Banana-ball.
News
Lions GM not concerned over closed Super Bowl window despite coaching exodus
As Detroit Lions general manager Brad Holmes spoke about the playoff exit to the Washington Commanders in the divisional round of the postseason, he now speaks about the foreseeable future. After the Lions lost offensive and defensive coordinators Ben Johnson and Aaron Glenn to…
NFL Makes Huge Jared Goff Announcement After Career Season
Jared Goff and the Detroit Lions capped off the season with a 15-3 record. The Lions were one of the most dominant teams in the NFL throughout the season and entered the playoffs as the No. 1 team in the NFC standings. Despite…
A Completed Trade Between the Canadiens and Devils Just Took an Unexpected Turn
We have an interesting development following a trade between the Montreal Canadiens and the New Jersey Devils. As you know, last March, Kent Hughes traded Jake Allen for a conditional 3rd-round pick, which could become a 2nd-round pick if Allen plays more…
Jake Evans Finally Reveals His Contract Demands, and the Details Are Surprising
We have some new information regarding the much-talked-about contract situation of Montreal Canadiens forward Jake Evans. I believe everyone agrees on keeping Evans with the Canadiens, but of course, it all depends on the price. Well, we finally have news about…
St-Louis Reveals Owen Beck’s Replacement for Tonight’s Game and Makes Two Announcements
As we mentioned this morning, Montreal Canadiens head coach Martin St-Louis made the decision not to hold a morning skate. Therefore, we had to wait for the press conference of the day to find out about the lineup changes for…
Beautiful Sight Live From Canadiens Practice as Reinforcements Could Join the Lineup Soon
We have news about Emil Heineman for you, thanks to the TVA Sports network. In the last few minutes, the network shared images of Heineman, who was on the ice in Brossard. This means that, while Canadiens players are in Detroit, Heineman…
End of content
No more pages to load