The New York Yankees find themselves navigating a delicate situation as the 2025 spring training approaches: the conspicuous absence of a reliable backup catcher. While Austin Wells has cemented his position as the primary backstop, the organizational depth chart behind him remains precariously thin. Following several strategic but potentially risky offseason moves, the Yankees must address this crucial roster gap before the regular season commences.

Austin Wells: The mainstay

AP Photo/Reed Hoffmann
Amid the backup catcher uncertainty, Austin Wells represents a cornerstone of the Yankees’ catching future. His 2024 performance demonstrated a promising blend of defensive competence and offensive potential. However, his durability will play a crucial role in determining the urgency of securing a reliable backup.

Wells’ ability to handle the pitching staff while maintaining offensive productivity could influence the profile of his eventual backup. A healthy, productive Wells might allow the Yankees to opt for a defense-first, cost-effective solution, but any performance decline or injury could expose the team’s vulnerability at the position.

Trevino’s departure sparks Yankees’ depth concerns

NY POST
The decision to trade Jose Trevino in exchange for strikeout artist Fernando Cruz represented a calculated gamble by the Yankees’ front office. While the move strengthened their bullpen, it created a significant void in their catching corps. Trevino’s declining defensive metrics in 2024, particularly his diminished throwing accuracy, made him expendable, but his departure, coupled with his manageable $3.45 million salary, raises questions about the team’s catching strategy.

The situation became more complex with the trade of Carlos Narvaez to Boston. Although acquiring promising flame-thrower Elmer Rodriguez-Cruz – whose repertoire features an electric triple-digit fastball – aligned with the organization’s pitching development goals, it further depleted their catching reserves. These moves, while individually justifiable, have collectively left the Yankees scrambling for solutions behind Wells.

Yankees’ current catching depth chart

The Yankees’ current options behind Wells present a mixture of uncertainty and untapped potential:

Alex Jackson: The likely placeholder

mlb
Alex Jackson, who arrived as part of the Fernando Cruz transaction, emerges as the most experienced option, though his track record raises concerns. His 2024 statistics tell a sobering story: a .122 batting average and a severely underwhelming 26 OPS+ suggest offensive limitations that could prove problematic. Despite occasional displays of power, including a memorable home run against former teammate Nestor Cortes Jr., Jackson’s struggles at the plate overshadow his defensive capabilities.

J.C. Escarra: The underdog with pop

mlb
The emergence of J.C. Escarra provides an intriguing narrative. The 29-year-old left-handed hitter’s remarkable Triple-A performance – a .302 average, .930 OPS, and eight home runs in 52 games – hints at untapped potential. His path from independent baseball to the Yankees system exemplifies perseverance, yet his limited experience at the highest level creates legitimate concerns about his readiness for a major league role.

Jesus Rodriguez: The long-term prospect

instra@jr23rod
Jesus Rodriguez represents the organization’s future behind the plate. At 22, his recent addition to the 40-man roster protected him from Rule 5 Draft exposure, reflecting his value to the franchise. However, his development timeline suggests 2025 would be premature for regular major league action, making him an unlikely solution for the immediate backup role.

External options: The search for experience

The Yankees’ internal uncertainty might necessitate exploring the free-agent market. Christian Vázquez stands out among available veterans, offering proven defensive excellence and valuable experience. However, his previous $10 million salary with Minnesota could prove prohibitive, especially given the Yankees’ current payroll considerations.

The market for experienced catchers has largely dried up, with most viable options already securing roles elsewhere. This timing challenge compounds the difficulty of finding an established backup through free agency, forcing the Yankees to weigh the merits of investing in a veteran against maintaining roster flexibility.

Potential wild cards

The Yankees‘ history of unexpected roster moves suggests multiple paths forward. An under-the-radar trade acquisition or a veteran minor league signing could emerge as viable solutions. The organization’s respected player development system might also accelerate the progression of internal candidates like Escarra, potentially creating an organic solution to their backup catcher dilemma.

Looking ahead

As the Yankees approach spring training, resolving their backup catcher situation becomes increasingly urgent. Their offseason moves reflect a willingness to sacrifice present depth for future potential, as evidenced by the departures of Trevino and Narvaez. However, the absence of a clear succession plan behind Wells could impact their championship aspirations.

The resolution may come through internal development, external acquisition, or some combination thereof, but the Yankees must establish reliable catching depth to support their 2025 campaign. For a team built to contend, solidifying this position could prove crucial to maintaining competitive balance throughout the season.

The backup catcher storyline will likely remain prominent as the Yankees fine-tune their roster for opening day, understanding that their decision could significantly influence their pursuit of another World Series title.